bestoflocal

Ranking · Auto repair shops · Jefferson

Birmingham Auto repair shops Rankings

We scored 119 Birmingham businesses offering auto repair shops on five measures you can check yourself. These are the 10 highest scores, with every number behind them.

Top 3 Auto repair shops in Birmingham

Local Score out of 100, with the numbers behind it and a direct quote request.

  1. 01

    65.9Local Score

    Robe Mans Automotive Service

    Homewood · ★ 4.8 · 548 reviews

    No review trend yet

    CheckedOperating status

    Request a quoteData profile

  2. 02

    64.3Local Score

    Mavis Tires & Brakes

    Birmingham · ★ 4.7 · 608 reviews

    No review trend yet

    CheckedOperating status

    Request a quoteData profile

  3. 03

    63.7Local Score

    Mavis Tires and Brakes

    Irondale · ★ 4.7 · 494 reviews

    No review trend yet

    CheckedOperating status

    Request a quoteData profile

More Auto repair shops in Birmingham

Out of 100. The right-hand column shows new reviews per 90 days, measured from review count snapshots.

  1. 04
    Express Oil Change & Tire EngineersBirmingham · ★ 4.8 · 416 reviews
    65.0
    –no trend yet
  2. 05
    Mavis Tires and BrakesBirmingham · ★ 4.7 · 478 reviews
    63.6
    –no trend yet
  3. 06
    Crane Fast LubeGardendale · ★ 5.0 · 97 reviews
    63.1
    –no trend yet
  4. 07
    Vulcan Tire & AutomotiveTrussville · ★ 4.8 · 208 reviews
    62.7
    –no trend yet
  5. 08
    Duffy's GarageBirmingham · ★ 4.8 · 178 reviews
    62.1
    –no trend yet
  6. 09
    A+ Tire & Auto RepairBirmingham · ★ 4.9 · 115 reviews
    62.1
    –no trend yet
  7. 10
    Precision Tune Auto CareBirmingham · ★ 4.7 · 261 reviews
    61.6
    –no trend yet
Birmingham average Local Score: 53.3How every score is calculated →
Also analyzed (109):
  • Green Garage 61.6
  • PTL Auto & Tire Center 61.2
  • Durrell Tire and Auto 60.7
  • Mavis Tires and Brakes 60.6
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 60.3
  • Autotread Mobile Tire Service 60.1
  • Acme Muffler 59.6
  • AAMCO Transmissions 59.2
  • Joe Hudson's Collision Center 59.0
  • Element Garage 58.9
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 58.7
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 58.5
  • Russell's Speed Shop 58.2
  • M&B Transmissions and Auto Repair 58.0
  • Audi Birmingham Service Center 57.8
  • TAPCO Premier Auto Repair 57.7
  • Tire Town 57.7
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 57.3
  • Brown Automotive 57.2
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 57.0
  • Lee-Rodgers Tire 56.7
  • RC Motors 56.7
  • Elite Tire & Service 56.6
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 56.6
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 56.6
  • New Metro Auto Service 56.3
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 56.1
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 56.1
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 56.0
  • Express Oil Change & Service Center 55.9
  • Mackin’s Garage 55.9
  • Adair Tire Pros 55.6
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 55.4
  • Harris Automotive 55.2
  • S+S Automotive Specialists 55.2
  • Big Moe Spring and Alignment 55.1
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 55.1
  • Precision Tune Auto Care 55.0
  • R & R Muffler & Brake 54.8
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 54.4
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 54.2
  • Edwards Chevrolet Body Shop 54.0
  • Gardendale Wholesale Transmission & Automotive 54.0
  • Mota Autohaus 53.7
  • Springville Road Auto & Tire 53.7
  • Fleet Pros Truck And Trailer Repair 53.6
  • Oxmoor Automotive 52.9
  • McGriff Tire & Service 52.8
  • Express Oil Change & Tire Engineers 52.6
  • Windham & Bush 52.4
  • Knight Automotive 52.3
  • Superior Automotive 52.2
  • Action Tire Co 52.1
  • City Tire & Auto Llc 52.1
  • Hatfield Auto Parts and Service 52.0
  • Mays Auto Service Inc 52.0
  • Eurasian Auto Service 51.8
  • Estes Automotive 51.6
  • Goff's Radiator & Electric Inc 51.6
  • Southern Rubber Tire 51.6
  • United Car Care Center 51.5
  • AAMCO Transmissions 51.3
  • Bimmer Motor Works LLC 51.2
  • Hanvey Tire and Auto Repair 51.2
  • Jim Burke Body Shop 51.2
  • Accel Auto Repair 51.0
  • Firestone Complete Auto Care 51.0
  • Kerklin Automotive Inc 51.0
  • Precision Automotive Machine 50.9
  • Kurt's Truck and Parts Co 50.8
  • Midas 50.8
  • Omega Tires 50.6
  • Scott's Auto & Tire 50.6
  • Alfa Romeo of Birmingham 50.4
  • Rpmextreme 50.3
  • Supreme Automotive Custom and Collision Center 50.3
  • Hesco Automotive and Performance Center 50.1
  • Oporto Madrid Tires 50.0
  • Magic City Auto Works 49.9
  • Aamco Transmissions & Total Car Care 49.2
  • Genesis Tire and Service 49.1
  • Snider Fleet Solutions 49.0
  • Tucker Paint & Body 48.9
  • J's Automotive 48.8
  • L and E Auto Repair 48.8
  • Mr. T's Automotive 48.8
  • World Transmission Specialist 48.8
  • I.N. Touch Automotive and Performance 48.6
  • Birmingham Benz Inc 48.1
  • Bennette's Motor World 48.0
  • Gray Auto Service Center Inc 47.9
  • Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires 47.8
  • Firestone Complete Auto Care 47.6
  • Cadillac Service 47.0
  • K & M Muffler & Brake 47.0
  • Adamson Collision Center 46.7
  • Iron City Tire and Auto 46.5
  • Decatur Highway Trans & Motor 46.3
  • Wholesale Transmissions 45.9
  • Tire Tech 45.7
  • Speedy Tire & Service 44.4
  • C Ray Tire And Auto Service Center 44.0
  • Jones Alton Auto Service 43.9
  • Spencer's Garage 43.7
  • Hoss Automotives 43.6
  • Car Works 42.7
  • K-n-a Auto Repair 42.6
  • David Cagle's Automotive 41.2
  • Center Point Wholesale Transmission 40.7

Score breakdowns

Each measure is scored 0–100, then weighted. The tick marks the average of all 119 businesses analyzed.

This businessBirmingham average

01

Robe Mans Automotive Service

65.9 Local Score

Rating
86
Reviews
91
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Reviews (91), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

02

Mavis Tires & Brakes

64.3 Local Score

Rating
79
Reviews
93
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Reviews (93), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

03

Mavis Tires and Brakes

63.7 Local Score

Rating
79
Reviews
90
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Reviews (90), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

Show breakdowns for #4–#10
05

Mavis Tires and Brakes

63.6 Local Score

Rating
79
Reviews
89
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Reviews (89), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

06

Crane Fast Lube

63.1 Local Score

Rating
93
Reviews
66
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Rating (93), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

07

Vulcan Tire & Automotive

62.7 Local Score

Rating
84
Reviews
77
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Rating (84), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

08

Duffy's Garage

62.1 Local Score

Rating
84
Reviews
75
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Rating (84), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

09

A+ Tire & Auto Repair

62.1 Local Score

Rating
88
Reviews
69
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Rating (88), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

10

Precision Tune Auto Care

61.6 Local Score

Rating
78
Reviews
81
Recency
50
Experience
0
Profile data
80

Strongest on Reviews (81), weakest on Experience (0).

Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews.

CheckedOperating status

How the Local Score works

The same formula for every business. Full detail on our methodology page.

Five measures, fixed weights

  • Rating30%
  • Reviews20%
  • Recency20%
  • Experience15%
  • Profile data15%

Who is ranked. An active listing, a phone number, a rating of at least 4.0 and 10 or more public reviews.

Ties. Scores show one decimal; on a tie, more recent reviews rank higher.

Corrections. Report a wrong number; we check the source within five working days.

We never sell score increases.

Businesses can pay us for a claimed profile, leads or competitor reports. None of it touches the score. How we make money

The Birmingham auto repair shops market

All 119 businesses analyzed, compared with the top 10.

Median rating

4.5

Top 10 average 4.79

Median reviews

68

Top 10 average 340

Average years in business

–

Top 10 average –

Average Local Score

53.3

Top 10 average 63.4

How Birmingham auto repair shops are rated

  • 4.8 – 5.029
  • 4.5 – 4.746
  • 4.0 – 4.444
  • Under 4.00

Average measure scores, all analyzed

  • Rating65
  • Reviews61
  • Recency50
  • Experience0
  • Profile data76

Data note: a missing measure is scored on the evidence we have and flagged on the card. License checks shown are from public records on the date listed.

Jefferson in numbers

Public records that size the market. They show how busy a trade is, not how good a business is, so they are not part of the score.

Figures from public sources. Rows tagged "Sample figure" show what our live public-data feeds will supply; they are illustrative, not real counts. Public records size the market and are not part of the score.

Request quotes from the ranked businesses

Free. Only the businesses you tick receive it. We may earn a fee; it never changes a score.

Send my request to
Choose more businesses (7)

We never sell your details. A business that answers may pay us a small fee; your price is the same.

Questions about this ranking

How is the top 10 ranking of auto repair shops in Birmingham calculated?

Each business gets a score from its rating, review volume, recent reviews, years in business, profile completeness and record checks. The highest scores make the list. We compared 119 auto repair shops for Birmingham.

Which of these auto repair shops in Birmingham has the best reviews?

Crane Fast Lube has a 5.0 rating from 97 public reviews, the highest on this page.

Which of these auto repair shops has the most reviews?

Mavis Tires & Brakes, with 608 public reviews. A long review history shows how a business handles many jobs.

Are these auto repair shops licensed?

10 of the 10 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check.

How many quotes should I get for auto repair shops in Birmingham?

Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.

Same method, different market.

Run a auto repair shops business in Birmingham?

See exactly where your score comes from and what's holding it back. Claim your free profile to check your data, fix anything that's wrong and get an alert when your rank changes.