--- title: Tire shops in Tallahassee: Top 10 by Local Score | BestOfLocal url: https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/tire-shops/ updated: 2026-10-31 --- [bestof **local**](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) - [Tallahassee rankings](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/) - [Tire shops](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tire-shops/) - [Methodology](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) - [For businesses](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/) 1. [Home](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) 2. [Florida](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/florida/) 3. [Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/) 4. Tire shops Ranking · Tire shops · Leon # Tallahassee Tire shops Rankings We scored 37 Tallahassee businesses offering tire shops on five measures you can check yourself. These are the 10 highest scores, with every number behind them. **37** businesses analyzed Updated October 31, 2026 Ranked Top 10 of 37 Reviews counted 21,696 Average score 55.9 Paid placements None in this ranking How the score works [Cost guide](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/guides/tire-shops-cost-tallahassee/) ## Top 3 Tire shops in Tallahassee Local Score out of 100, with the numbers behind it and a direct quote request. 1. 01 **68.0** Local Score ### [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-724b1af94b036e84/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.8 · 2,701 reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-724b1af94b036e84/) 2. 02 **67.9** Local Score ### [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/mavis-tires-brakes-tallahassee/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.8 · 1,638 reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/mavis-tires-brakes-tallahassee/) 3. 03 **62.2** Local Score ### [Jim Wells Tire Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ff43126151ad91ca/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.9 · 114 (2021) reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ff43126151ad91ca/) ### More Tire shops in Tallahassee Out of 100. The right-hand column shows new reviews per 90 days, measured from review count snapshots. 1. 04 [Proctor Subaru](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-subaru-tallahassee/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.9 · 3,575 reviews **69.9** – no trend yet 2. 05 [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-126ae693e90a7e0a/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.8 · 2,142 reviews **67.9** – no trend yet 3. 06 [Proctor Acura](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-acura-tallahassee/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.8 · 1,554 reviews **67.9** – no trend yet 4. 07 [Discount Tire](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-9cbbf715d19ca305/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.5 · 1,016 reviews **62.0** – no trend yet 5. 08 [Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/pep-boys-auto-service-tires-tallahassee/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.5 · 1,271 reviews **62.0** – no trend yet 6. 09 [Peter Boulware Toyota Service Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/peter-boulware-toyota-service-center-tallahassee/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.5 · 1,152 reviews **62.0** – no trend yet 7. 10 [Tire Choice Auto Service Centers](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ba28ca4e0d784a69/) Tallahassee · ★ 4.7 · 208 (2021) reviews **60.9** – no trend yet Tallahassee average Local Score: **55.9** [How every score is calculated →](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) **Also analyzed (27):** - Discount Tire 60.6 - Tallahassee Ford 60.0 - Tire Town Automotive Center 58.9 - The Tire Centre of Florida 57.9 - Real Deal Custom Wheels and Tires 57.5 - Tire Town & Muffler 56.5 - Auto Xperts Monroe - a Main Street Auto shop 56.4 - Boulevard Tire Center 56.2 - Capital Volkswagen 55.9 - Precision Tune Auto Care 55.5 - Neece Tire and Auto Service 53.6 - Tire Kingdom 53.3 - B & B Tires 52.2 - Big A's Tire & Wheel 51.7 - Furrin Auto Alley 51.4 - Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires 50.7 - Westside Tire and Brake 50.4 - Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires 49.5 - Firestone Complete Auto Care 49.3 - Tires Plus 49.1 - Big A's Tires South 49.0 - Thompson Services Of Tallahassee LLC 48.9 - Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires 48.6 - Jose's Tire & Car Service 48.5 - Barrons Wholesale Tire 46.7 - Tire Kingdom 46.4 - Affordable Tires 41.5 ## Score breakdowns Each measure is scored 0–100, then weighted. The tick marks the average of all 37 businesses analyzed. This business Tallahassee average 01 ### [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-724b1af94b036e84/) **68.0** Local Score Rating **86** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-724b1af94b036e84/) · Request a quote 02 ### [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/mavis-tires-brakes-tallahassee/) **67.9** Local Score Rating **86** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/mavis-tires-brakes-tallahassee/) · Request a quote 03 ### [Jim Wells Tire Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ff43126151ad91ca/) **62.2** Local Score Rating **88** Reviews **69** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (88), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ff43126151ad91ca/) · Request a quote Show breakdowns for #4–#10 04 ### [Proctor Subaru](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-subaru-tallahassee/) **69.9** Local Score Rating **93** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-subaru-tallahassee/) · Request a quote 05 ### [Mavis Tires & Brakes](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-126ae693e90a7e0a/) **67.9** Local Score Rating **86** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-126ae693e90a7e0a/) · Request a quote 06 ### [Proctor Acura](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-acura-tallahassee/) **67.9** Local Score Rating **86** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/proctor-acura-tallahassee/) · Request a quote 07 ### [Discount Tire](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-9cbbf715d19ca305/) **62.0** Local Score Rating **66** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-9cbbf715d19ca305/) · Request a quote 08 ### [Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/pep-boys-auto-service-tires-tallahassee/) **62.0** Local Score Rating **66** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/pep-boys-auto-service-tires-tallahassee/) · Request a quote 09 ### [Peter Boulware Toyota Service Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/peter-boulware-toyota-service-center-tallahassee/) **62.0** Local Score Rating **66** Reviews **100** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (100), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/peter-boulware-toyota-service-center-tallahassee/) · Request a quote 10 ### [Tire Choice Auto Service Centers](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ba28ca4e0d784a69/) **60.9** Local Score Rating **78** Reviews **77** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Profile data (80), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-ba28ca4e0d784a69/) · Request a quote ## How the Local Score works The same formula for every business. Full detail on our [methodology page](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/). ### Five measures, fixed weights - Rating **30%** - Reviews **20%** - Recency **20%** - Experience **15%** - Profile data **15%** **Who is ranked.** An active listing, a phone number, a rating of at least 4.0 and 10 or more public reviews. **Ties.** Scores show one decimal; on a tie, more recent reviews rank higher. **Corrections.** [Report a wrong number](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/); we check the source within five working days. **We never sell score increases.** Businesses can pay us for a claimed profile, leads or competitor reports. None of it touches the score or the order. If a business is a paying customer, its data profile says so. [How we make money](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/how-we-make-money/) ## The Tallahassee tire shops market All 37 businesses analyzed, compared with the top 10. Median rating 4.5 Top 10 average **4.72** Median reviews 138 (2021) Top 10 average **1537** Average years in business – Top 10 average **–** Average Local Score 55.9 Top 10 average **65.1** ### How Tallahassee tire shops are rated - 4.8 – 5.0 **10** - 4.5 – 4.7 **10** - 4.0 – 4.4 **17** - Under 4.0 **0** ### Average measure scores, all analyzed - Rating **65** - Reviews **74** - Recency **50** - Experience **0** - Profile data **77** **Data note:** a missing measure is scored on the evidence we have and flagged on the card. License checks shown are from public records on the date listed. ### Leon in numbers Public records that size the market. They show how busy a trade is, not how good a business is, so they are not part of the score. - Median home value **$294,400** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates](https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT5Y2024.B25077?g=160XX00US1270600) · 2020–2024 · Median value of owner-occupied homes (ACS table B25077). - Homes built before 1990 **53.3%** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates](https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT5Y2024.B25034?g=160XX00US1270600) · 2020–2024 · 51,828 of 97,245 housing units were built in 1989 or earlier (ACS table B25034, year structure built). - Households in Tallahassee **85,311** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates](https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT5Y2024.B25003?g=160XX00US1270600) · 2020–2024 · Occupied housing units (one household per occupied home), ACS table B25003. - Atlantic hurricane season **June 1 to November 30** Source: [NOAA National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Climatology](https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/climo/) · 1991–2020 climate period · An average season (1991–2020) has 14 named storms, 7 hurricanes and 3 major hurricanes. - Median year homes were built **1988** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates](https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT5Y2024.B25035?g=160XX00US1270600) · 2020–2024 · Half of all housing units were built before this year (ACS table B25035). - Owner-occupied homes **40.6%** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates](https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT5Y2024.B25003?g=160XX00US1270600) · 2020–2024 · 34,661 of 85,311 occupied homes are lived in by their owners (ACS table B25003). - Tallahassee residents **204,902** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates](https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/2020-2025/cities/totals/sub-est2025.csv) · July 1, 2025 · Population estimate for July 1, 2025 (incorporated place). - Average summer high **91.5°F** Source: [NOAA NCEI, U.S. Climate Normals 1991–2020](https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/data/normals-annualseasonal/1991-2020/access/USW00093805.csv) · 1991–2020 normals · Normal daily maximum temperature for June to August; NOAA station Tallahassee (USW00093805), about 6 miles from the city center point. Figures from public sources. Rows tagged "Sample figure" show what our live public-data feeds will supply; they are illustrative, not real counts. Public records size the market and are not part of the score. ## Request quotes from the ranked businesses Free. Only the businesses you tick receive it. We may earn a fee; it never changes a score. Send my request to Choose more businesses (7) ## Questions about this ranking ### How is the top 10 ranking of tire shops in Tallahassee calculated? Each business gets a score from its rating, review volume, recent reviews, years in business, profile completeness and record checks. The highest scores make the list. We compared 37 tire shops for Tallahassee. Paid placements never change the order. ### Which of these tire shops in Tallahassee has the best reviews? Proctor Subaru has a 4.9 rating from 3575 public reviews, the highest on this page. ### Are these tire shops licensed? 10 of the 10 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check. ### How many quotes should I get for tire shops in Tallahassee? Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request. ## Related rankings Same method, different market. - [HVAC Contractors Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/hvac-contractors/) - [Air Duct Cleaning Companies Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/air-duct-cleaning-companies/) - [HVAC Repair Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/hvac-repair/) - [HVAC System Replacement Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/hvac-replacement/) - [AC Repair Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/ac-repair/) - [Emergency AC Repair Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/emergency-ac-repair/) - [AC Maintenance & Tune-Up Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/ac-maintenance/) - [AC Installation & Replacement Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/ac-replacement/) - [Tire shops, Jacksonville](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/jacksonville/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Miami](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/miami/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Tampa](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tampa/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Orlando](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/orlando/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Port St. Lucie](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/port-st-lucie/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, St. Petersburg](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/st-petersburg/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Cape Coral](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/cape-coral/tire-shops/) - [Tire shops, Hialeah](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/hialeah/tire-shops/) - [What tire shops cost in Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/guides/tire-shops-cost-tallahassee/) ## Run a tire shops business in Tallahassee? See exactly where your score comes from and what's holding it back. Claim your free profile to check your data, fix anything that's wrong and get an alert when your rank changes. [Claim your free profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/)[Report a data error](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/) - [Home](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) - [Tallahassee](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tallahassee/) - [Tire shops](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tire-shops/) - [Methodology](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) - [How we make money](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/how-we-make-money/) - [Corrections & update log](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/) - [Claim a profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/) - [About](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/about/) - [Contact](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/contact/) - [Data sources](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/data-sources/) - [Privacy](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/privacy/) - [Terms](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/terms/) BestOfLocal rankings are calculated from public data using the published formula. Positions and scores are never for sale. We may earn a fee when you request a quote through a business's profile. Data last updated October 31, 2026 . © 2026 BestOfLocal.