--- title: Auto repair shops in Caldwell: Top 10 by Local Score url: https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/auto-repair-shops/ updated: 2026-11-04 --- [bestof **local**](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) - [Caldwell rankings](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/) - [Auto repair shops](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/auto-repair-shops/) - [Methodology](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) - [For businesses](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/) 1. [Home](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) 2. [Idaho](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/idaho/) 3. [Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/) 4. Auto repair shops Ranking · Auto repair shops · Canyon # Caldwell Auto repair shops Rankings We scored 31 Caldwell businesses offering auto repair shops on five measures you can check yourself. These are the 10 highest scores, with every number behind them. **31** businesses analyzed Updated November 4, 2026 Ranked Top 10 of 31 Reviews counted 3,746 Average score 56.7 How the score works [Cost guide](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/guides/auto-repair-shops-cost-caldwell/) ## Top 3 Auto repair shops in Caldwell Local Score out of 100, with the numbers behind it and a direct quote request. 1. 01 **65.6** Local Score ### [Roger's Tire Pros & Auto Care Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-c59091e5b15cc686/) Caldwell · ★ 4.7 · 857 reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-c59091e5b15cc686/) 2. 02 **62.0** Local Score ### [General Automatic Transmission](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-d1d1c9e5a90fd5cb/) Caldwell · ★ 5.0 · 57 reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-d1d1c9e5a90fd5cb/) 3. 03 **59.5** Local Score ### [Perfection Tire and Auto Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-117188e236adce18/) Middleton · ★ 4.6 · 198 reviews No review trend yet Checked Operating status Request a quote [Data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-117188e236adce18/) ### More Auto repair shops in Caldwell Out of 100. The right-hand column shows new reviews per 90 days, measured from review count snapshots. 1. 04 [Jbj Diesel Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-2a34090f406fc229/) Caldwell · ★ 4.9 · 164 reviews **64.3** – no trend yet 2. 05 [Caldwell Automotive](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-58c9f24c04b9916a/) Caldwell · ★ 4.9 · 84 reviews **62.0** – no trend yet 3. 06 [Little Man Auto Care](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-a9ce7994324120b7/) Nampa · ★ 4.9 · 134 reviews **60.6** – no trend yet 4. 07 [Andy's Transmissions & Auto](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-db8612dc96b5ebdf/) Caldwell · ★ 4.9 · 58 reviews **60.6** – no trend yet 5. 08 [Jiffy Lube Oil Change and Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-b893f6845fafb470/) Caldwell · ★ 4.6 · 247 reviews **60.1** – no trend yet 6. 09 [Sevy Auto Repair And Tires](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-648e6ee54fdf2a2f/) Marsing · ★ 5.0 · 28 reviews **59.0** – no trend yet 7. 10 [Phil's Auto Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-56443d4fb7d1a0f9/) Caldwell · ★ 4.8 · 54 reviews **58.9** – no trend yet Caldwell average Local Score: **56.7** [How every score is calculated →](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) **Also analyzed (21):** - Valvoline Instant Oil Change 58.2 - Jerry's Repair Service 57.7 - Busted Knuckle Auto Center 57.1 - American Muffler & Auto Repair 57.0 - Archers Auto Repair 57.0 - Demented Diesel & Auto 57.0 - Kenworth Sales Caldwell 56.5 - [Les Schwab Tire Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-9bf5ac1efad24eb0/) 56.4 - [United Muffler & Brake](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-6cc6ecd0cd2e2752/) 55.9 - [Commercial Tire](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-69c293c151ecee3f/) 55.7 - [Heavy Metal Truck & Equipment Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-d2aeff36c4395058/) 55.6 - Cooper's American Service 55.4 - Moore Truck Repair 55.4 - Muffler Mill 55.3 - [Commercial Tire](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-7cbc8f9d376a022f/) 55.1 - [4x4 Shop Inc.](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-a38be0d37e668211/) 54.6 - [R & R Muffler & Welding](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-f6c16a846c01f444/) 53.4 - Superior Paint & Glass 51.9 - Beckham Collison Center 50.8 - [Gallegos Auto Repair & Towing](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-c9bfe76994b7a610/) 45.7 - United Radiator Shop 44.6 ## Score breakdowns Each measure is scored 0–100, then weighted. The tick marks the average of all 31 businesses analyzed. This business Caldwell average 01 ### [Roger's Tire Pros & Auto Care Center](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-c59091e5b15cc686/) **65.6** Local Score Rating **80** Reviews **98** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Reviews (98), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-c59091e5b15cc686/) · Request a quote 02 ### [General Automatic Transmission](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-d1d1c9e5a90fd5cb/) **62.0** Local Score Rating **94** Reviews **59** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (94), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-d1d1c9e5a90fd5cb/) · Request a quote 03 ### [Perfection Tire and Auto Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-117188e236adce18/) **59.5** Local Score Rating **74** Reviews **77** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Profile data (80), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-117188e236adce18/) · Request a quote Show breakdowns for #4–#10 04 ### [Jbj Diesel Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-2a34090f406fc229/) **64.3** Local Score Rating **92** Reviews **74** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (92), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-2a34090f406fc229/) · Request a quote 05 ### [Caldwell Automotive](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-58c9f24c04b9916a/) **62.0** Local Score Rating **90** Reviews **64** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (90), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-58c9f24c04b9916a/) · Request a quote 06 ### [Little Man Auto Care](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-a9ce7994324120b7/) **60.6** Local Score Rating **91** Reviews **71** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **60** Strongest on Rating (91), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Profile data incomplete: some details such as hours, website or founding year are missing. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-a9ce7994324120b7/) · Request a quote 07 ### [Andy's Transmissions & Auto](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-db8612dc96b5ebdf/) **60.6** Local Score Rating **89** Reviews **59** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (89), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-db8612dc96b5ebdf/) · Request a quote 08 ### [Jiffy Lube Oil Change and Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-b893f6845fafb470/) **60.1** Local Score Rating **74** Reviews **80** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Profile data (80), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-b893f6845fafb470/) · Request a quote 09 ### [Sevy Auto Repair And Tires](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-648e6ee54fdf2a2f/) **59.0** Local Score Rating **91** Reviews **49** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (91), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-648e6ee54fdf2a2f/) · Request a quote 10 ### [Phil's Auto Repair](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-56443d4fb7d1a0f9/) **58.9** Local Score Rating **84** Reviews **58** Recency **50** Experience **0** Profile data **80** Strongest on Rating (84), weakest on Experience (0). Recency scored at a neutral 50: not enough review history yet to measure new reviews. Checked Operating status [Full data profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/business/g-56443d4fb7d1a0f9/) · Request a quote ## How the Local Score works The same formula for every business. Full detail on our [methodology page](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/). ### Five measures, fixed weights - Rating **30%** - Reviews **20%** - Recency **20%** - Experience **15%** - Profile data **15%** **Who is ranked.** An active listing, a phone number, a rating of at least 4.0 and 10 or more public reviews. **Ties.** Scores show one decimal; on a tie, more recent reviews rank higher. **Corrections.** [Report a wrong number](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/); we check the source within five working days. **We never sell score increases.** Businesses can pay us for a claimed profile, leads or competitor reports. None of it touches the score. [How we make money](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/how-we-make-money/) ## The Caldwell auto repair shops market All 31 businesses analyzed, compared with the top 10. Median rating 4.8 Top 10 average **4.83** Median reviews 57 Top 10 average **188** Average years in business – Top 10 average **–** Average Local Score 56.7 Top 10 average **61.3** ### How Caldwell auto repair shops are rated - 4.8 – 5.0 **17** - 4.5 – 4.7 **6** - 4.0 – 4.4 **8** - Under 4.0 **0** ### Average measure scores, all analyzed - Rating **78** - Reviews **60** - Recency **50** - Experience **0** - Profile data **76** **Data note:** a missing measure is scored on the evidence we have and flagged on the card. License checks shown are from public records on the date listed. ### Canyon in numbers Public records that size the market. They show how busy a trade is, not how good a business is, so they are not part of the score. - People per square mile **3,017** Source: [Calculated from U.S. Census Bureau 2025 estimates and Gazetteer land area](https://www.census.gov/geographies/reference-files/time-series/geo/gazetteer-files.html) · 2025 - Land area **25.4 sq mi** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, 2025 Gazetteer files](https://www.census.gov/geographies/reference-files/time-series/geo/gazetteer-files.html) · 2025 - Caldwell residents **76,629** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025)](https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2020s-total-cities-and-towns.html) · July 1, 2025 - Population change since 2020 **+27.4%** Source: [U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025)](https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2020s-total-cities-and-towns.html) · 2020–2025 · from 60,138 (April 2020 base) Figures from public sources. Rows tagged "Sample figure" show what our live public-data feeds will supply; they are illustrative, not real counts. Public records size the market and are not part of the score. ## Request quotes from the ranked businesses Free. Only the businesses you tick receive it. We may earn a fee; it never changes a score. Send my request to Choose more businesses (7) We never sell your details. A business that answers may pay us a small fee; your price is the same. ## Questions about this ranking ### How is the top 10 ranking of auto repair shops in Caldwell calculated? Each business gets a score from its rating, review volume, recent reviews, years in business, profile completeness and record checks. The highest scores make the list. We compared 31 auto repair shops for Caldwell. ### Which of these auto repair shops in Caldwell has the best reviews? General Automatic Transmission has a 5.0 rating from 57 public reviews, the highest on this page. ### Which of these auto repair shops has the most reviews? Roger's Tire Pros & Auto Care Center, with 857 public reviews. A long review history shows how a business handles many jobs. ### Are these auto repair shops licensed? 10 of the 10 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check. ### How many quotes should I get for auto repair shops in Caldwell? Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request. ## Related rankings Same method, different market. - [HVAC Contractors Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/hvac-contractors/) - [Brake repair shops Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/brake-repair-shops/) - [Transmission repair shops Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/transmission-repair-shops/) - [Tire shops Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/tire-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Jacksonville](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/jacksonville/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Miami](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/miami/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Tampa](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/tampa/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Orlando](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/orlando/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Port St. Lucie](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/port-st-lucie/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, St. Petersburg](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/st-petersburg/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Cape Coral](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/cape-coral/auto-repair-shops/) - [Auto repair shops, Hialeah](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/hialeah/auto-repair-shops/) - [What auto repair shops cost in Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/guides/auto-repair-shops-cost-caldwell/) ## Run a auto repair shops business in Caldwell? See exactly where your score comes from and what's holding it back. Claim your free profile to check your data, fix anything that's wrong and get an alert when your rank changes. [Claim your free profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/)[Report a data error](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/) - [Home](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/) - [Caldwell](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/caldwell/) - [Auto repair shops](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/auto-repair-shops/) - [Methodology](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/methodology/) - [How we make money](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/how-we-make-money/) - [Corrections & update log](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/corrections/) - [Claim a profile](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/claim/) - [About](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/about/) - [Contact](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/contact/) - [Data sources](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/data-sources/) - [Privacy](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/privacy/) - [Terms](https://bestoflocalrankings.com/terms/) BestOfLocal rankings are calculated from public data using the published formula. Scores are never for sale. We may earn a fee when you request a quote through a business's profile. Data last updated November 4, 2026 . © 2026 BestOfLocal.